Facebook Reads the Android Gallery: €805 Million Fine in Italy, and What to Check at Home
Italy's data protection authority (the Garante) fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million on 14 November 2026. According to the Garante's press release, the Facebook app for Android read photos, videos and metadata from the galleries of Italian users without valid consent and without informing them properly. The authority puts the number of affected Android users at about 20 million.
If Facebook runs on a phone in your household, the case is worth a look. It shows what a photo permission, granted once, actually allows.
What a gallery permission means
A gallery permission is the system-level consent that lets an app read photos and videos on the device. At the "all photos and videos" level it covers the whole archive, usually permanently, even when the app only needs one picture. The system does not distinguish between a holiday snapshot and a photo of your passport.
The authority writes that neither users nor the regulator can check which information is actually used. On a family phone the gallery holds pictures of children, scans of documents, screenshots from banking apps and photos of number plates or house keys. According to Meta's own help page, a suggestion such as "post this photo from yesterday?" only needs the capture time, favourite status and media type. The permission covers everything regardless.
What the regulator documents
Everything in this table comes from the Garante's press release of 14 November 2026 (primary source, read):
| Point | Content |
|---|---|
| Feature | "Get suggestions from your gallery while browsing Facebook", available since 2023, proposes gallery photos and videos as post ideas |
| Trigger | Complaint by a consumer centre in Bolzano, proceedings since July 2025 |
| Finding 1 | One permission for the whole app and several features with different needs |
| Finding 2 | The preceding notice ("enable other features") does not mention the gallery |
| Finding 3 | The feature was switched on by default |
| Legal basis | Art. 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, implementing the ePrivacy Directive |
| Amount | €805 million, about 0.47% of group worldwide turnover |
| Deadline | 60 days for a separate consent request; default "off", also for existing users |
The authority also rejects Meta's argument that the Irish regulator is competent: the ePrivacy rules have no one-stop-shop mechanism. The proceedings did not examine whether content was used to train AI, which Meta denies. A new 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud will get a separate review.
What Meta says, and what stays open
According to press reports (Il Fatto Quotidiano, CBS/AFP), Meta disagrees with the assessment, calls the fine disproportionate and announces an appeal; CBS gives the sum in US dollars (880 million in its headline), the Garante gives 805 million euros. Meta points out that the feature needs a device permission and can be changed in settings at any time. Both statements are vendor claims, and the decision is not yet final.
Facebook's help page describes the suggestions as using metadata such as capture time, favourites and media type. A separate "cloud processing" option uses Meta's generative AI. TechCrunch reported in June 2025 that this option uploads media to Meta's servers on an ongoing basis. In an April 2026 announcement (vendor statement) Meta says the new suggestion feature is opt-in in the EU and UK and that the photos are not used to improve its AI unless you share them yourself.
The two features can be switched separately; for the US test phase TechCrunch names two toggles under "Camera roll sharing suggestions". Turning off only the first one may leave the cloud option on. That is why the checklist below covers both.
Where you can limit the access
The operating system is the strongest place. Android 14 introduced "Selected photos": an app sees only the pictures you pick in the system dialog (Android Developers, verified). On the iPhone, Settings, Privacy & Security, Photos lists every app that has asked for access, and you can switch it off per app (Apple, verified). The in-app switch in Facebook comes second, because it turns off the feature itself even when the permission stays.
Household checklist
- Open the Facebook app on every family device: menu, Settings and privacy, Settings, then the entry for suggestions from your camera roll (the help page calls it "Suggestions for sharing content from your camera roll"). Switch off "Get suggestions from your camera roll while browsing Facebook". According to Facebook the setting applies to all devices where the app has access. Switch off cloud processing there too, if it is offered.
- Android: Settings, Apps, Facebook, Permissions, Photos and videos. Choose "Don't allow" or, where it exists, the selected-photos option. Menu names differ by manufacturer; Google's help describes the path through Apps and Permissions.
- iPhone: Settings, Privacy & Security, Photos. Set each app to "None" or a limited selection.
- Pick photos instead of opening the archive: when you want to post a picture, choose it in the system dialog. Few apps need standing access to the whole gallery.
- Check children's and spare devices separately. If the Facebook app is opened rarely, the permission was often granted years ago.
The same applies to company phones. What we offer businesses is on the services page. The same principle, as few rights per program as possible, runs through prompt injection and agent permissions. More texts sit in the security and privacy hub.
Open points
We did not run the Facebook app ourselves and measured no menus on our own devices. The menu paths come from Facebook's help page, Google's Android help and Apple's guide. Of the decision we read only the press release, not the full text. It is unclear whether the German Android app shows the same consent flow and whether other EU regulators will take up the case; none of the sources we read says anything about that. The decision is not final because, according to press reports, Meta announced an appeal, and whether and when a court rules is open.
Read next: Philips Hue Bridge: Pwn2Own flaws in the HomeKit service · Synology C2 Identity Edge Server and its CVSS discrepancy · Google Fonts and the warning letters before the CJEU
Further Reading
- Garante Privacy, press release 14 Nov 2026 (verified)
- Facebook Help: turn camera roll suggestions on or off (vendor statement)
- Meta: opt-in camera roll suggestions in the EU and UK, April 2026 (vendor statement)
- Android Developers: Selected Photos Access (verified)
- Apple: Control access to information in apps on iPhone (verified)
- Android Help: Change app permissions (verified)
- TechCrunch, 27 Jun 2025: cloud processing (reported)
- Il Fatto Quotidiano, 14 Nov 2026 (reported)
- CBS News/AFP, 14 Nov 2026 (reported)
Does the decision apply in Germany or the rest of the EU?+
Legally it binds Meta towards the Italian authority and concerns Italian users. The rule behind it implements the EU ePrivacy Directive, so the test is not specifically Italian. We have not measured whether the Facebook app shows the same flow in Germany. The Facebook help page for the toggle exists in German.
Did Meta use the photos to train AI?+
The authority did not examine that and says so explicitly. Meta denies it. For the newer cloud feature, which uploads photos for AI processing, the Garante reserved a separate review.
Is uninstalling the Facebook app enough?+
For the gallery problem, yes, if you do not need the app. If you do use it, the in-app switch plus the photo permission in the operating system covers it. Either one alone leaves a gap.
senn-tech